Picture this – you’re sitting in a beach chair, relaxing, when your phone buzzes. You pick it up and see a message from work. You quickly type out a response, just enough to keep people from realizing you’re gone.
Does this sound familiar? If so, you might have experienced quiet vacationing.
Quiet vacationing is the act of taking time off, but not informing your boss that you’re taking that time off. You don’t request PTO, you don’t set up an out-of-office notice, and you maintain the appearance that you’re still working, even if you’re not.
The term has gained popularity recently, particularly after a 2024 Harris Poll survey of U.S. workers. The survey asked about “out-of-office culture,” and a significant number of respondents indicated that they take time off without telling their employers.
People are still taking time off to rest and recharge, but instead of requesting that time off, they’re hiding it. The question is, why do so many people feel like they need to hide it in the first place?
The Reality of a Quiet Vacation
A 2024 Harris Poll found that nearly four out of ten millennials have admitted to taking time off without informing their manager. There are many tricks people use to “pull it off.”
For example, one common trick is to schedule emails or Slack messages to be sent in the early morning or late evening to give the appearance of being active, when in fact you spend a significant portion of the time off the clock. In fact, the same Harris Poll found that a significant number of millennials admitted to scheduling messages to give the impression of being online longer than they actually are.
Another trick is to use mouse jigglers, either USB devices or apps that simulate cursor movement to prevent Teams or Slack from changing your status to idle or “away.” Wells Fargo even fired over a dozen employees in 2024 for simulating keyboard activity to avoid being detected as away. Another trick is to schedule brief check-ins, perhaps from a beach, hotel, or airport, so you can respond quickly to a message and “prove” you’re there.
The stress of quiet vacationing comes from having to keep your phone in hand at all times, to check for notifications, and the half-rest of never fully being present on your vacation, or fully present at work. It’s a constant state of worry that you’ll be called on a video call or asked to do something important at a moment’s notice.
If you have to lie about being online to be on vacation, is it really a vacation at all?
The Real Difference Between Quiet Quitting and Vacationing
Quiet quitting is the act of pulling back on work efforts to the bare minimum, putting in the bare minimum amount of effort necessary to not get fired. The phrase went viral on TikTok in mid-2022, and as of 2022, Gallup estimated that at least 50% of U.S. workers are “quiet quitters.”
Quiet vacationing, meanwhile, isn’t about pulling back on effort. It’s about hiding where you are or that you’re taking time off. That same Harris Poll, conducted for Bloomberg, found that 28% of workers overall took time off without telling their boss.
The biggest difference between the two is that quiet quitting is about effort, while quiet vacationing is about trust.
Ironically, many of the people who take quiet vacations are very invested in their jobs. So, why would someone working hard at their job still feel the need to hide from their employer?
Why do some workers never take their PTO?
If you’ve ever written a PTO request but never hit send, you know the feeling. Some people feel a kind of guilt over asking for time off, like they’re asking for a favor. Some people dread the response, or the lack thereof, from their manager.
Some people are afraid of seeming less dedicated to their role than their peers. After all, if you’re not available, you’re not dedicated, right?
Some people are afraid of being next on the layoff list. If you’re not around, what proof is there that your role is necessary?
Some people are afraid of coming back and facing a mountain of work and an overflowing inbox. What better way to punish someone for taking time off, right?
What the Pew Data Shows
A survey by the Pew Research Center, published in March of 2023, found that 46% of workers with PTO benefits take less than what they’re given.
52% said they don’t feel like they need more time off. 49% worry about falling behind in their work. 43% feel bad about the work their colleagues have to do in their absence.
19% worry that taking more time off will hurt their chances of advancement. 16% worry that they’ll lose their job. While fear of losing a job is a big reason people avoid taking PTO, fear of falling behind is a greater concern, at least according to Pew.
Quiet vacationing is a way to avoid this dilemma. You can take time off without requesting it and can enjoy some relaxation and rest without the fear of what will happen.
One of the biggest questions is: are people afraid because of tangible signs, or because of the silence?
Tangible signs are things like remarks about absences or praise for people who are always available. Silence, meanwhile, is no one setting an example, and no one mentioning what the expectations are. When managers don’t speak up, unspoken social norms fill in the gap.
Unlimited PTO policies add to the confusion by making it unclear what an acceptable amount of time off is.
What does faking it at work really cost?
As with the section on U.S. laws, I’m not going to spend any time re-introducing this topic, since you know what it is and why I’m talking about it.
The first downside is a breach of trust. If your managers or bosses find out that you’ve been pulling these tricks, they’re going to look back on every time you’ve been “online” during your work hours and wonder if you were actually working. You might have coworkers who cover for you, but if they don’t know you’re not actually working and find out later, they’re going to feel used.
The second downside is that if something slips through the cracks, it slips through the cracks. If you’re not actually at work and someone needs something from you, they might be sending urgent messages that you never see, or trying to get approval from you for something that never happens, or waiting on you to hit a deadline you don’t know about. It’s not just you who suffers from these issues – it’s your clients, your customers, and more.
The third downside is that you could lose your job. Most employment in the United States is at-will (Montana is the exception, here). That means your employer can fire you for pretty much any reason. Usually, if they want to fire you, they’ll try to build a case of poor performance to do it. However, if they find out you’re faking it, they’re likely to frame it as misconduct rather than performance issues. Depending on your state, that can impact your ability to collect unemployment benefits if you’re fired.
The Wells Fargo firings mentioned earlier, disclosed through FINRA and reported by Bloomberg, show this is a real risk.
This should serve as a warning that tricks like mouse jigglers aren’t foolproof. Employers are increasingly turning to software that monitors activity like keystrokes and idle time, and they can see when something is wrong.
The Hidden Cost of Never Resting
All of this is to mention the quieter, but still important, downside of quiet vacationing – you’re never fully resting.
This is a problem for two reasons. The first is that studies on recovery from work show that psychological detachment is essential to recovery. When you’re not fully detached, you’re not fully recovering. The second is that the World Health Organization, in its ICD-11, lists burnout as an occupational phenomenon, characterized by exhaustion, cynicism, and reduced professional effectiveness.
In the kindest possible terms, quiet vacationing is a reasonable choice to make, but it has a high cost. Is it worth it to you to steal a day off and hide it? I’ll leave that up to you to decide.
If you’re starting to wonder if there’s a way to build a team where everyone can rest safely, read on.
Build a Team That Feels Safe to Rest
If you’re looking at this and thinking about how to discipline people for quiet vacationing, I have a different perspective. Quiet vacationing is a cultural symptom, not a disciplinary problem.
When people feel the need to hide their time off, it means they don’t feel safe asking for time off. Disciplining them addresses the symptom, but not the problem – the fear remains in place.
One of the more important concepts in management is psychological safety. Psychological safety was popularized by Amy Edmondson, a professor at Harvard Business School, in her 1999 paper “Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams” for Administrative Science Quarterly.
Amy Edmondson says psychological safety is a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking. She also wrote a book about the subject, “The Fearless Organization,” which was published in 2018. Another example of psychological safety comes from Google’s Project Aristotle, which examined the teams at Google and determined the key dynamics that make teams effective. The five key dynamics are:
Taking time off is a form of interpersonal risk.
To counteract this, you need to cultivate a culture where it’s acceptable to take time off.
Leaders Set the Example
Leaders taking time off is a good way to set the example. When leaders take time off, and truly take time off – not answering emails from the beach, but actually disconnecting – and announce to the team that they’re doing so, it becomes a cultural norm.
A company saying “take your PTO” while the boss is always available is a dissonant message. Similarly, some companies like LinkedIn and Bumble have taken entire weeks off in 2021 to demonstrate the same idea.
Another simple action is to require a clear handoff plan for any time off, which should include:
- A specific individual who can cover each responsibility
- A brief status document for any ongoing work
- An out-of-office message that directs people to the backup individual
A team calendar where everyone can see planned time off is also useful.
When everyone has a clear handoff plan, no one feels guilty about “leaving people in the lurch” when they take time off.
You can also use management to encourage people to take time off. Rather than just approving time off requests, encourage people to book time off.
Talking about unused PTO balances in one-on-ones, or checking in periodically to make sure people aren’t falling behind and facing a crunch at the end of the year, can be a good way to do this. Be careful, though.
Why More Tracking Backfires
One of the worst things you can do to encourage psychological safety is to add more tracking software. Microsoft’s Work Trend Index 2022 report coined the term “productivity paranoia” to describe the state of modern work, where 87% of employees believe they are productive, but 85% of leaders say they struggle to trust productivity in a hybrid environment.
The more you add in monitoring and tracking, the more people will feel the need to game the system. This is why you see things like mouse jigglers and fake keyboard activity.
The more surveillance you add to the workplace, the more people will feel the need to go even deeper underground with their rest.
There are a lot of other factors at play here, from Australia’s right to disconnect taking effect in August 2024, to the whole discussion about what would make your team feel safe to ask for time off. What do you think?
1 Project Aristotle studied over 180 different Google teams. 2 Daimler’s “Mail on Holiday” system automatically deletes emails sent to employees while they’re on vacation. 3 Unlimited PTO can actually lead to people taking less time off, as well.
4 Pew Research Center 2023: 46% of workers say they take less time off than they are allowed, often because they worry about falling behind on their work or about making their coworkers work more to cover for them. 5 Volkswagen blocked after-hours email access on BlackBerry for some employees in 2011. 6 France’s right to disconnect went into effect in January 2017.
7 Amy Edmondson says psychological safety does not mean lowering the bar on performance or quality.
Close the Gap Between Words and Actions
So, what’s the key takeaway here?
It’s the disconnect between what you say and what people experience. You say one thing, “take your PTO,” but your daily behaviors say another.
From the employee’s perspective, you might feel guilty, fearful, or anxious about the work waiting for you when you return, so you hide that you’re resting. But that leaves you losing out on trust and on actual relaxation.
From the manager’s perspective, you might be confused why your dedicated and hard-working employees are hiding their time off from you.
The truth is, it all comes down to trust and clarity. When there’s silence and undefined expectations, people fill in the gaps with fear.
The truth is, both of you want the same thing – to be able to count on each other to do their work and take their rest. But when you both have clear roles, clear expectations, and clear plans for coverage, there’s no need to hide.
What if, instead of worrying about asking for time off, you could request it like it was the most natural thing in the world? What would that do for your business?
At HRDQ Store, our Accountability Experience assessment and workshop helps you build a culture of trust-based accountability, rather than surveillance-based accountability. Teams learn to operate with more clarity on their roles, managers can more effectively foster engagement and close the gap between expectation and delivery, and everyone can feel less stress in their daily lives.
Leave a Reply