Energize your room. Reinforce the skills.Explore Games

What Is the Pygmalion Effect and How It Shapes Teams

·

What is the Pygmalion Effect and How it Shapes Teams

Expectations travel long before anyone actually says anything. A manager who has already written a person off will start sending out signs without even meaning to (a shorter leash, not as many opportunities to step up, and less eye contact in meetings). The person on the receiving end picks up on it pretty fast, and they’ll usually start pulling back on their effort to match what they feel is expected of them. That cycle tends to run in either direction.

Most leaders legitimately want their teams to do well – and most would say they give everyone a fair shot. What’s harder to catch is that many of them carry quiet assumptions about who has what it takes and who has already peaked. Those assumptions usually formed in the first few weeks and were never revisited after that. They shape day-to-day decisions in ways that don’t feel like a big deal – who gets the harder project, who gets talked over and who earns the trust to lead a client call. The distance between what a manager believes about an employee and what that person could become can be remarkably large.

The Pygmalion effect is the formal name for this, and it’s grounded in decades of research across classrooms, military units, and corporate offices. The core finding has held up consistently across all of that – high expectations lift performance when they’re genuine and paired with support. Low expectations suppress it.

What makes this especially tricky is how subtly it operates. A manager never has to say a single negative word out loud for some damage to happen. The team member still feels it – in the tone of feedback, in who gets tapped for which projects, and in how much room they’re given to run with an idea. Most employees will rise or fall to meet whatever bar has been set for them. And a high bar can create an environment where your team legitimately wants to step up.

Let’s talk about how the Pygmalion effect can change the way your team thrives!

The 1968 Study That Started It All

The Pygmalion Effect has its roots in a classroom study from the 1960s. Psychologists Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson walked into an elementary school in South San Francisco and told the teachers that a handful of their students were on the verge of a big intellectual breakthrough.

The 1968 Study That Started It All

Those students had been chosen at random (with no criteria, no regard for test results, nothing) and by the end of the school year, quite a few randomly selected kids ended up showing greater IQ gains than their peers. That result did raise a question about why a random label would have that effect on a child’s entire school year.

The name itself actually has two separate origins. The first is an ancient Greek myth about a sculptor who falls madly in love with a statue he carved himself – and the statue eventually comes to life. The second is George Bernard Shaw’s famous play that borrowed that same premise and used it to look at how the peers and mentors around us can quite literally shape who we become. Those two stories point to the same core idea – what others believe about you has a way of eventually becoming true.

Not everyone accepted Rosenthal and Jacobson’s findings without some pushback, though. One researcher named Robert Thorndike had some problems with the study’s methods and with whether the data could hold up under closer scrutiny. That debate never went away – it’s still an active conversation in academic circles. But even with those criticisms, the pattern they identified has continued to surface in research across schools, workplaces, and plenty of other settings.

Report cards bring a version of this into nearly every household, and it goes almost the same way each time. A teacher writes a few words about what a child is capable of, and the parent’s view of their kid starts to change a bit – sometimes for the rest of that entire semester. The label lands, and it sticks, and the behavior that comes after is almost never just a coincidence.

How a Belief Turns Into Your Reality

At its core, their research revealed a chain reaction – a belief shapes how you act, your actions shape the effort that you put in, and then that effort shapes the results that you get. Sociologist Robert Merton had a name for this long before their experiment came along – he called it the “self-fulfilling prophecy.”

And it turns out this same pattern runs through workplaces just as reliably as it does in schools. Rosenthal eventually broke this whole chain down into four parts. A leader’s belief about a team member can subtly change the emotional climate around that person – along with the feedback they receive, how much input they’re given and how often they get invited to contribute their own ideas. All four of these factors tend to influence each other beneath the surface of nearly every team interaction.

What makes this so hard to manage is that most teams are pretty sharp at reading who their manager really believes in – and they usually figure it out within a few weeks. No one ever has to say a word about it – it all tends to leak through in all kinds of small ways. Signals like who gets pulled into a conversation, what work lands on whose desk, or whether someone’s ideas go anywhere after they’re shared – it all adds up pretty quickly.

How a Belief Turns Into Your Reality

The big problem with this loop is that it runs on its own – no one guides it, and no one even knows it’s happening. A manager almost never stops mid-interaction to ask themselves whether they’re treating a team member differently because their expectations of them are lower – it just runs quietly in the background.

That distance between what a leader actually believes and what they think they believe – that’s the exact space where the Pygmalion effect lives, and it’s also where teams can start to slowly drift apart without anyone ever seeing it.

The Quiet Damage of Low Expectations

The Pygmalion Effect has a darker twin. When a leader holds low expectations for someone on their team, those expectations like to pull that person down – just as reliably as high expectations lift others up. Psychologists call this the Golem Effect, and it runs on that same mechanism, only flipped in the other direction.

What makes this especially hard to see is that the damage tends to be invisible. Jean-François Manzoni and Jean-Louis Barsoux coined the term “set-up-to-fail syndrome” to describe how a manager’s quiet doubts about an employee slowly start to change how that person gets treated. The employee picks up on it, pulls back, and, at the end of the day, does just as poorly as the manager expected. No one plans for it to go that way, and usually neither of them realizes it is happening.

The Quiet Damage of Low Expectations

Most managers have at least one person on their team that they’ve more or less written off. In most cases, it’s not even a deliberate call – it’s more of a gut feeling that settled in after a rough first impression and just never quite left. And first impressions like to stay way longer than they probably should.

Once an employee gets labeled as “average” early on, something changes in how willing they are to put themselves out there. Fewer hands go up, fewer ideas get shared, and any appetite for the opportunities that might actually change how their colleagues see them fades pretty quickly. It’s hard to blame them for it. When a room has already made up its mind about who you are, changing that takes so much more energy than anyone wants to spend.

Expectations (low ones just as much as high ones) are anything but passive forces. They shape behavior in very real ways, and they do it almost invisibly over a long period of time.

The Signals You Send Without a Word

Belief has a way of leaking out even when you’re not saying a word. The tone that you use with one person versus another, the extra second that you give a colleague to find their words before you cut in, and how much independence you’re actually willing to hand over – it sends a message whether you mean it to or not.

Research in psychology has found that we can pick up on nonverbal cues with a great deal of accuracy in just a few seconds. These moments even have a name – scientists call them “thin slices,” small windows of behavior that give away far more about what a person believes than anything they might say out loud. For managers, that’s worth sitting with. Even if you look a team member in the eye and tell them you have full confidence in them, your body language can contradict every word of it without a sound.

The Signals You Send Without a Word

A few concrete examples can help make the point. Crossing your arms during a colleague’s presentation, cutting them off mid-sentence, or sending the most high-profile projects to the same two colleagues – your team picks up on it. More than that, it tells them pretty obviously where they stand with you. No amount of verbal encouragement will undo those kinds of repeated patterns over time. Think about the patterns on your own team.

It’s worth looking at who gets the stretch assignments, who gets cut off in meetings versus who always seems to get the floor with no resistance at all, and who you give a little extra room to fail versus who you hold to a tighter standard without even realizing it. None of that’s random. Every one of those patterns is a direct reflection of the expectations that you’re already carrying, whether you’ve ever examined them or not.

How High Goals Can Hurt a Team

The line between a goal that drives teams forward and one that drives them into the ground can be razor thin. Employees don’t rise to meet a target that feels too far out of reach – the response is more likely to be anxiety, exhaustion, and a slow fade where a person is physically present but mentally already gone.

Edwin Locke and Gary Latham dedicated decades of research to figuring out whether harder goals produce better performance. Their answer was yes – but with one condition attached to it. A goal has to feel within reach to have any real pull. Every bit of that motivational pull just vanishes the second a person stops believing a goal is attainable.

How High Goals Can Hurt a Team

The Wells Fargo fake accounts scandal is probably the most talked-about example of what goes wrong when that line gets crossed. Employees were handed sales targets so extreme that thousands of them ended up opening millions of unauthorized accounts just to hit their numbers – that level of pressure caused fraud on a massive scale. It’s one of the more extreme cases that you’ll ever come across. But the same basic pattern shows up in workplaces all the time, just at a much smaller scale.

Pressure and belief can look almost identical from a distance – that’s where the job gets a bit tough for managers. A leader who sets an aggressive target might feel like they’re expressing confidence in their team. But the team on the receiving end can walk away with a very different read – something that feels far more like a threat than a vote of confidence. Many teams describe stretch goals not as a sign that leadership believes in them but as a setup to fall short. That disconnect between what a leader intends to say and what employees actually hear is where the Pygmalion Effect can slowly start to work against everyone.

Real Belief Comes With Hands-On Support

High expectations only mean something when there’s actual substance behind them. A manager who never shows belief in their team (through honest feedback, genuine conversation, or a little patience now and then) might as well just be hoping everything works out on its own.

Carol Dweck’s research on the growth mindset gets at something worth sitting with. Performance tends to climb when a person believes that their abilities can improve. Usually, that belief gets handed to them by someone else. As a manager, you’re that someone else.

Real Belief Comes With Hands On Support

On a normal Tuesday afternoon, that belief almost never looks like a big motivational speech. In most cases it’s a quick five-minute check-in where you ask how something is going and legitimately listen to the answer. Or it’s a stretch assignment handed off with a quiet “I’m here if you need anything” that keeps you present in the background.

Google’s Project Aristotle (one of the most cited studies on what makes teams work) found psychological safety to be the single biggest driver. At its core, everyone needs to feel like they can speak up, get something wrong, or try something new without it coming back to bite them. When that trust isn’t there, even the most well-meaning feedback can start to feel more like pressure than support.

It’s a fine line, and it matters. When coaching comes with genuine trust behind it, your team feels like they have someone in their corner. Without that trust, the same coaching can start to feel like surveillance – like someone is hovering nearby and waiting for a mistake. The distance between those two experiences doesn’t need to be all that big for your team to feel it. Once they do, it changes everything about the way that they work.

The Way You See Your Team Matters

A leader’s beliefs about the employees around them have a very real effect on what those employees go on to produce – which is the whole point of everything that we’ve covered. Those beliefs make their way into everything a manager does. Every day-to-day choice a manager makes carries a little bit of that belief system along with it, and those choices add up fast. Over time, they shape the entire experience that an employee has at work – and that experience is what drives how well they perform at the end of the day.

Take a few minutes this week to look at who on your team has been given stretch assignments – and who gets handed the same predictable work over and over. Those patterns usually say more about a manager’s assumptions than they say about what anyone on the team is capable of. Pick one person who hasn’t had a fair shot to prove themselves and then ask yourself what it would take to give them one.

The Way You See Your Team Matters

Applause and grand gestures are nice. But that’s usually not what employees are after. What most of us legitimately want is to feel like the person above us actually believes that we’re capable of more. A leader’s take on someone (even when it goes unspoken) can slowly redirect the entire path that person ends up on.

If any of this resonates with what you’re working through on your own team, our Leadership 101 courseware at HRDQ was built for this work. It’s a strong resource for new and experienced managers alike – one with the tools to lead with more confidence, build stronger teams, and make decisions that turn intentions into long-term results.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Recent Posts

  • Imposter Syndrome at Work: Signs and How to Overcome It

    Imposter Syndrome at Work: Signs and How to Overcome It

    Have you ever dreaded a meeting where you know you’ll need to…

    Read more…

  • How to Use the Six Thinking Hats in Team Meetings

    How to Use the Six Thinking Hats in Team Meetings

    Meetings stuck in circles? Learn how to use the Six Thinking Hats…

    Read more…

  • What Is Social Loafing and How to Stop It on Teams

    What Is Social Loafing and How to Stop It on Teams

    Social loafing can make a team look productive while a few people…

    Read more…