icon Guide to Employee Self-Evaluation Tips (+Free Examples) Skip to content
Guide to Employee Self-Evaluation Tips (+Free Examples)

Guide to Employee Self-Evaluation Tips (+Free Examples)

The usefulness of self-evaluation isn't strictly tied to preparations for performance reviews. It's about nudging employees to write a thorough self-review, something good not only for their bosses or HR departments but for their own benefits, too. We're talking about motivating them to step up in their professional path.

Let's not overlook that, besides personal growth, effective self-evaluation also boosts employee motivation, polishes their skills, and improves productivity at work. It even clears up communication between management and employees and helps to create a work environment that respects honesty and effectiveness.

What does this mean for you as an employer? Let's talk about some of the fundamentals!

Recommended Assessment
What's My Leadership Style
  • Identify personal leadership styles
  • Capitalize on style strengths
  • Minimize style trouble spots
Learn more

Why Is Self-Evaluation Important?

Do you often look at yourself with a critical eye? Well, let us tell you, it's somewhat like using a mirror to see your reflection. You get a chance to see your work's impact, and you can notice the gap between where you are now and where you want to be. But what's the secret about this process?

A big part of this process is self-examination, that's right, checking out your own position. It's kind of like taking a snapshot of what you can do in your job, which can sometimes wake you up, in a sense. We're not just talking about skills here, though. This whole self-reflection is about understanding how you use those skills, what your mindset is, and what areas need a bit more of your attention. It's like wiping off a foggy mirror, and then you can see where you're doing great and where you could use a little work.

When you spot your strengths, you've got yourself an opportunity to polish them up. And those areas that seem a bit behind? They can become chances to learn new skills and move up the ladder. It gives you a view of where you need to improve and what abilities are required to get ahead in the company.

Conducting a Self-Evaluation

Looking at yourself as honestly as possible can stir up motivation. It's easy for employees to focus on what they haven't got or haven't done yet. But what about breaking out the party hats for the wins? Openly looking at yourself can help you keep in mind the wins – both big and small ones. It cheers on workers to acknowledge how far they've come, no matter how small the steps, firing up self-confidence and dreadnaught determination to aim higher.

Finally, giving yourself a good look helps align personal aims with the company's goals. By keeping track of their job performance, employees can smartly adjust their efforts to make a more significant impact toward reaching the company's targets. Keep in mind that employees aren't just parts of the machine. They play a big part in making the company's ultimate dreams come true.

Fundamentals of an Effective Self-Evaluation

Honesty sits at the heart of everything. Stop for a second and ask, are you really honest when you look at your performance? The point of looking at how you're doing isn't to just focus on your strong points or ignore where you might be falling short. Nope, it's about knowing where you shine and digging into where you can do better. Seriously, where do you stand when it comes to being honest?

Moving on, let's discuss relevance. Do you make sure to look at the right parts of your work? It's important to remember the stuff that directly links to what you do on an everyday basis and your role. Are you checking out your big tasks and victories, or do you find yourself wandering off into areas that don't really matter? Stick to looking at what means a lot to your job.

Effectively Completing a Self-Evaluation

Now, about being specific. Avoid skimming over things with just a comment or two about your work. For the best look at what you're doing, the nitty-gritty details are where it's at. Instead of saying you did "good" or "bad," break it down by looking at individual tasks and projects. For instance, did you reach your sales goal in the last three months? By how much or how little? Are you starting to see what we're talking about?

The last important bit is using facts, not feelings. Don't let your personal opinions get in the way, but focus on the real, observable stuff. You might've found yourself saying, "I feel" or "I think" a lot, right? Try turning your viewpoint to what can be measured or proven. An "I finished the project two days early" is going to be more effective than an "I feel like I put in a lot of effort."

While these aren't the only pieces to the puzzle, they get you off to a great start when you're ready to do right by your hard work and performance.

How to Start Your Self-Evaluation?

Starting a self-evaluation can feel a bit scary. But here's the good news: creating a clear plan or method can help make your thoughts clear and tidy. You might be wondering how you get the ball rolling.

Start by reviewing your job performance as a whole. Take time to recall your wins, the problems you faced, and areas where you improved during the set timeframe. Let us tell you, it's worth it to spend some time recalling your past work experiences.

Next up, gather up any relevant paperwork that shows your performance. These could be past performance reviews, feedback from your bosses or coworkers, or any awards you've won. Doing so will make your evaluation more thorough and supported by actual evidence. For instance, were your reports always sent in on time? Did your project get a shout-out from the bigwigs? Take a moment to think about these performance indicators.

Starting a Self-Evaluation

The next thing? Figure out your goals. Ask yourself what you want to achieve in your job. Are you looking to get more done, learn new skills, or perhaps take on a leadership role? Your self-evaluation should focus on how your actions are helping you get closer to these goals.

Plus, a significant part of your self-evaluation needs to be looking at where you slipped up. What were the roadblocks you came across? Was it making deadlines or sharpening technical skills? It's essential to examine these areas honestly – it shows you're proactive and self-aware and can help you figure out how to grow professionally.

Remember that your self-evaluation doesn't have to list every detail from the evaluation period. Instead, pick your most significant accomplishments, learnings, challenges, and goals to talk about. That gives you a chance to highlight your progress, your potential, and where you plan to put your effort in the future.

Here's some advice: Maintain a professional language and stick with the facts. That gives your self-evaluation a serious edge and makes it easier for others to confirm what you're saying. This mindset will also keep you from being too harsh on yourself or patting yourself on the back too much.

Using Action Verbs in Self-Evaluation

So, why are action words so important in a self-review? These straight-to-the-point words make your achievements crystal clear.

First, let's dig into "action words." These words describe something you do – a mental or physical action. When you do a self-review, they zoom in on your achievements. Action words make your contribution come alive and show you're ready to get things done, giving your review energy and drive.

Starting a serious self-review means you must be exact about your role, right? How did you make the team work better, simplify rules, or fix a longstanding problem? Action words have the answer, and they're spot on.

Using Action Words in Self-Evaluation

You could say, "I helped to make the workflow better." Or, you could say, "I kicked off changes to make our workflow smoother." Which phrase grabs more attention and shows off your role best? The second one.

Furthermore, action words put a positive spin on self-reviews. Saying, "I was the one to lead a team project successfully," paints you as a standout leader who's ready to take on challenges. "Led" is an action word that stands for taking charge, energy, and being responsible. Other positive action words include "completed," "got," "gave," "made better," "brought about," "solved," and "changed."

Action words also help you tell a more thorough story. Don't just describe your job; explain the particular stuff you brought to it. Maybe you "changed" how the team's documents were filed so key files were easier to find. Or did you "solve" a budget issue that saved the company a lot of money? Show off these specifics with action words, and give solid proof of what you've done.

Putting in action words is like telling a gripping, straightforward, short tale about what you've done at work. They hold a lot of power and make your contributions clear and engaging. So, don't just do a good job at work; show it off well during review time. Yes, using action words right is a skill. Get good at it for a self-review that makes a real impression. It's all about how you say it; "being part of a project" or "getting a successful project off the ground." Which sounds better? And you see, action words aren't just words; they're the stars of your story.

Common Mistakes to Avoid in Self-Evaluation

Doing a self-check brings chances for personal improvement and strong self-support. Yet, there's a twist. Some problems might play around with the benefits of this tactic if you don't handle them smartly. Have you ever felt confused, not ready, or just unsure of what to write down? Many people go through this; it's not only you. A bit of advice can help you avoid these common slip-ups.

To begin with, don't hold back too much. Does that raise an eyebrow? Even though being humble is a good thing, being too shy about your successes in a self-check might hide your actual achievements. Remember that it's not boasting – it's just a reminder of what you've reached. You've put in the effort, so why not let it show in your evaluation?

But beware – don't go overboard, either. Nobody appreciates a bragger – especially not your boss. Listing every small win or pumping up your successes lessens the influence of your real skills and talents. So, how do you find the balance? Prioritize your successes.

Steer clear of unclear terms. Are your points clear, measurable, achievable, suitable, and set within a timeframe (SMART goals)? Let's get serious: general sayings like "I worked hard" don't resonate without tangible evidence. Make your points sharper with specific examples.

Performing a Self-Evaluation

Another trap is to focus only on the bright side. Sounds strange, right? Everyone has stuff they can work on. If you don't mention any, your check might come off as unrealistic and not honest. Your goals for self-betterment are a pathway to your future achievements. Don't shut out your weak points; see them as opportunities for improvement instead.

Last but not least, remember the comments you've received over the year. This feedback – often overlooked – is a treasure of valuable information. Did you explore these remarks? Were you careful about reacting, and did follow-up actions come after?

Dodging these common errors can turn your self-check into an engaging story about your achievements, areas for improvement, and career hopes. Steer clear from too much bragging or pointless statements. Let your self-check show an actual record of your progress and possibility. It's more than doable to avoid these mistakes. Put forth the real, balanced professional you are. After all, isn't that the person you've been trying to evolve into?

Examples of Employee Self-Evaluation

If you find yourself as a project manager handling many tricky tasks for a significant project, in your self-assessment, you stress your knack for managing many jobs simultaneously. We're talking about something like, "During Q4, I managed resources, schedules, and plans for seven projects at once, and never missed any big deadlines."

Suppose you're in customer service. You might mention an instance where you showcased excellent communication and problem-solving skills; "Once, I encountered an irate client. I listened carefully, identified their issue, and presented a custom-made solution that turned their frown into a grin."

What if sales are your thing? In a self-assessment, you would shine a light on significant sales accomplishments. You'd say something like, "This financial year, I exceeded my sales target by 18%. I cultivated great relationships with important clients and really took advantage of a new sales approach."

An Employee Self-Evaluation

Let's consider PE teachers, who have many roles to play. A fitting self-assessment might read: "This year, I developed a new PE curriculum that mixed traditional sports with cool, new games. We saw a 15% rise in student involvement and fun."

It's pretty clear that no two jobs are exactly the same, right? So, there's no one single way to write self-assessments. What's important is to adjust your assessment according to each role and to be honest and reflective about your performance.

Let's take an example where you juggle several roles in one job. It could sound like, "Juggling my admin duties and team lead role has taught me how to multitask effectively. Not only did I organize three team-building events this year, but I also maintained a 95% completion rate for all my tasks."

There are so many roles out there and just as many examples of self-assessments. The big common factor here? Being honest, reflective, and articulate!

Add Our Employee Assessment Tests to Your Toolkit

Reflecting on what we've learned from this simple guide, we realize that self-evaluation has many uses beyond being nice to have. No, it's something you truly need if you're an employee looking to grow. It's more than a skill – it's a way of life. Have you thought about what it could do for you?

We've dug into the many parts of self-evaluation, breaking it down to the basics – from figuring out what counts in a good self-evaluation to handy tips to help you write one and great templates to show you the way. But it's down to you, the individual, to get involved with this process. Are you ready to get into the details of self-reflection for growth?

Employees Reviewing Assessment Tests

Sure, it's essential for you to take charge of your development, but the part human resources play and the evaluation tools an organization offers can't be overlooked. That is where our employee assessment tools and tests step into the spotlight.

We have many employee assessment tools and tests that have been designed to look into each essential area of soft-skill training. They are excellent resources, whether you're into old-school classroom learning or more into on-site training. These tools will help you spot where you're going wrong, build on your strong points, and make the most of what you and your team can do.

Take advantage of these assessment tools and shape your future with confidence. As you keep up with your self-evaluation habit, remember these methods and techniques are there to help you sharpen your skills and build a mindset focused on ongoing growth!

Previous article Enneagram Guide: Types, Tests, Assessments & More
Next article Merit Increases in 2024: Everything You Need to Know

Leave a comment

Comments must be approved before appearing

* Required fields

About our author

Bradford R. Glaser

Brad is President and CEO of HRDQ, a publisher of soft-skills learning solutions, and HRDQ-U, an online community for learning professionals hosting webinars, workshops, and podcasts. His 35+ years of experience in adult learning and development have fostered his passion for improving the performance of organizations, teams, and individuals.